Processing Speed: The NFL Draft's Hardest-to-Measure Skill
Five strategies for students to process the world like an NFL quarterback.
Posted April 24, 2026 | Reviewed by Monica Vilhauer Ph.D.
Like many of my patients, I have always dreamed of being a professional athlete. That dream was never realistic for me, and many decades into my life, any athletic feat is a cause for celebration.
But I am still an avid sports fan, and I am particularly interested in understanding what makes for a great player. And one of my favorite events is the NFL draft, where evaluations of future performance often ride on intangible skills that neuropsychologists measure in our work.
Obviously, a basic requirement is the physical component of sports. You will never be an NFL quarterback without being able to throw a football a long way, accurately, with pace. You will never play in the NBA without speed, quickness, and the ability to shoot.
We are now in the season of the NFL Draft. The NBA Draft follows at the end of June. I listen to dozens of podcasts about these drafts, and I keep noticing that the skill scouts praise in their best prospects is the one that matters just as much for my patients, whether they become recreational, high school, college, or professional athletes, or never play at all.
That skill is processing.
What we actually measure in the office
One way I explain processing speed to parents is by describing how we take in information from the outside, bring it into our brains, process it there, and then produce an output.
What our tests measure most readily is the speed of that process. But there is some mystery about what actually goes on inside the brain between input and output.
As neuropsychologists, we often measure the speed of doing something rather than how long it takes the brain to process and make sense of information. Our instruments tap visual scanning, clerical motor speed, reaction time, and the ability to balance speed with accuracy. All of that is useful. But it does not capture what draft analysts mean when they talk about a player's mind.
Speed of doing versus speed of processing
Speed of doing is how fast your finger hits the button or your pencil moves. It is measurable and important.
Speed of processing is different. In the case of an NFL quarterback, it includes recognizing what is occurring beforehand, looking at a field of changing objects, reading a defensive formation, and finding the pattern. It involves anticipating where a receiver will be open microseconds later. It involves holding several possibilities in mind and updating them rapidly as new information arrives.
Other factors sit alongside this: Intuition , which may be a capacity to pick up on cues most observers miss; film study, which makes recognition automatic; and confidence in decisions, which is the willingness to make a call fast and live with it rather than puzzle over it.
Why scouts end up watching tape
I do not want to call any of this unmeasurable. But these skills are far more difficult to discern than arm strength or 40-yard-dash time, whether NFL teams are trying to draft the next great quarterback, linebacker, or safety.
Consider Caleb Downs, the Ohio State safety who was drafted eleventh in the recent draft. Mel Kiper Jr., known as the NFL Draft Guru, wrote that Downs “diagnoses quickly thanks to excellent pre-snap instincts,” which lets him play faster than his timed speed suggests. Todd McShay of The Ringer compared him to Ed Reed, noting that Reed was the best ever at knowing what was about to happen before it happened. Downs' processing, in McShay's view, can almost allow him to see the future.
The NFL runs prospects through a rigmarole of tests: tracking data, computer vision, combined drills, and psychological evaluations. Sophisticated tools can now measure in-game speed and certain reaction times. But we still cannot peer inside the brain to watch a decision form. Which is why, in the end, the best scouts fall back on the same thing I do in my office: watching what the person has done over many years.
Here is an interesting twist for parents. The same technology that makes screen time a concern for many of the kids I see, including fast-moving video games, high-stimulation apps, and media that reward split-second decisions, is also the technology now being used to train and evaluate elite processors.
Five strategies for kids from the quarterback playbook
If processing is hard to see, it is also hard to train through ordinary means. Here is where we can borrow from athletes. Here are five strategies neurodivergent students can take from how quarterbacks prepare:
No one is measuring any of this precisely. But the NFL has built a multibillion-dollar industry around figuring out which twenty-two-year-olds have the mind for the game. We might borrow from what they have learned.
McShay, T. (Host). (2023–present). The McShay Show [Audio podcast].
Jr., M. K., & Authors, M. (2026, April 23). 2026 NFL Draft Big Board Rankings: Mel Kiper’s Top Prospects . ESPN. https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2026/story/_/id/46573669/2026-nfl-draft-r…
Share this post Facebook Bluesky Linkedin Email
There was a problem adding your email address. Please try again.
By submitting your information you agree to the Psychology Today Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy
Randy Kulman, Ph.D. , is a child clinical psychologist, parent of 5, and founder of LearningWorks for Kids. He is the author of Train Your Brain for Success and Playing Smarter in a Digital World .
Get the help you need from a therapist near you–a FREE service from Psychology Today.
This article is part of the Bringwise Psychology Journal — daily insights on human behavior, mental health, and personal growth.