Exploring the Role of Bystanders in the Elizabeth Smart Case
What made the bystanders intervene and what can we learn from their actions?
Posted February 2, 2026 | Reviewed by Monica Vilhauer Ph.D.
Picture the scene: You’re walking downtown, and you see someone who resembles the wanted poster for a suspect in a child abduction 9 months ago. Do you (1) trust your judgment and call the police or (2) shrug it off, assume you must be mistaken, and carry on with your day? The case of Elizabeth Smart highlights four people who found themselves in exactly that situation, and whose courage, awareness, and commitment to being active bystanders played a crucial role in bringing a missing child home.
Elizabeth Smart was abducted from her bedroom in Salt Lake City, Utah, in June 2002 at the age of 14, with her younger sister as the only witness. For nine months, she was held captive by her abductors, Brian David Mitchell and Wanda Barzee, and was moved around a range of locations while disguised with a face-concealing shroud. Several months after the abduction, Elizabeth’s sister Mary Katherine realised that the person who had been in their bedroom that night was ‘Emmanuel’, a man who had previously completed work at the Smart’s home. ‘Emmanuel’ was later identified as Brian David Mitchell, and his picture was circulated within the media, including on the television show America’s Most Wanted .
The Active Bystander Moment
The turning point in the case occurred in March 2003, when members of the public noticed a man accompanied by two veiled women in Sandy, Utah. The man matched the public description of the suspect, and the women appeared withdrawn and avoided eye contact. Two different couples on the street in Sandy that day trusted their instincts when they thought they recognised Mitchell, and both contacted Sandy Police to share the location of the group. This decision proved critical, as police quickly responded, questioned the individuals, and ultimately confirmed the girl’s identity as Elizabeth Smart. The actions of the active bystanders in Sandy that day led directly to Elizabeth’s rescue.
The Psychology of Active Bystandership
From a psychological perspective, the bystanders’ action in Sandy highlights several key factors that support active bystander behaviour:
The role of active bystanders in the Elizabeth Smart case demonstrates that the decisions of a stranger can play a decisive role in preventing ongoing harm. Law enforcement efforts and media coverage were essential in this case, but they weren’t enough on their own. It took the actions of attentive citizens who were willing to act to ultimately change the outcome of the case. This serves as a compelling reminder that individual actions matter. By noticing, trusting their instincts, and being willing to act, the Sandy bystanders demonstrated that each one of us has the power to disrupt harm and save lives, simply by being willing to step up and act.
Butler, L. C., Graham, A., Fisher, B. S., Henson, B., & Reyns, B. W. (2022). Examining the effect of perceived responsibility on online bystander intervention, target hardening, and inaction. Journal of interpersonal violence , 37 (21-22), NP20847-NP20872.
Liu, Y. L., Jian, T. E., & Wang, C. Y. (2025). Utilizing VR technology to explore the moral courage process and bystander behaviors: An experimental trial. Computers in Human Behavior Reports , 17 , 100596.
Silver, E. (2023). Bystander reporting on a college campus: Moral intuitions as a precursor to informal social control. Deviant Behavior , 44 (3), 398-420.
Vera, E. M., Galvin, S., Millon, F., Drapcho, R., & Payne, H. (2023). Culturally-Motivated bullying and bystander intervention: The role of witness situational awareness, intervention history, and victim race. Journal of Prevention and Health Promotion , 4 (1), 3-30.
Share this post Facebook Bluesky Linkedin Email
There was a problem adding your email address. Please try again.
By submitting your information you agree to the Psychology Today Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy
Gill Harrop, Ph.D., is a Registered Forensic Psychologist specializing in the use of active bystandership and psychological strategies to address problematic relationship behaviour and tackle crime.
Get the help you need from a therapist near you–a FREE service from Psychology Today.
This article is part of the Bringwise Psychology Journal — daily insights on human behavior, mental health, and personal growth.